We live in houses, drive cars, and depend upon technology. Despite this, our lives still depend upon the health of the natural environment - air, soil, and water.

Businesses, politicians, and citizens around the world continually struggle with the question: how can we improve our standard of living and keep the environment healthy?

Is it possible to do both?

The debate over how we interact with our natural environment shapes our news every day.

The struggle over natural resources - who owns them and how best to use them - has also shaped the history of our nation and our region.

This cedar paddle handle bears the marks of the adze that was used to carve it. At the time of its donation to the historical society, the donor reported that this paddle belonged to Nisqually Chief Leschi.
Washington State Historical Society Collections.
 

Your Assignment: You are going to have the opportunity to pretend that you have been hired to mediate, or help others resolve, a conflict that has occurred over the natural resources of the Nisqually River watershed in Washington's Puget Sound region.

To do this, you must conduct research into historic uses of the river and into contemporary issues. How have different groups of people used the Nisqually River watershed's resources? What are some of the problems that remain?

Primary Sources: A piece of evidence created during the time period under investigation by someone who participated in, witnessed, or commented upon the events that you are studying. It is the surviving record of past events such as photographs, diaries, or artifacts.

As a consultant, you will write a report that persuasively offers a resolution to the conflict. Part of your job will be to analyze, cite, and interpret artifacts, and primary and secondary sources. You will examine at least two different groups of people who have been living in the Nisqually River watershed beginning in the 1800s - the Nisqually Indian Nation and either British fur traders and their descendants, or American settlers and their descendants.

Let's begin!

Part I. Review Setting of the Conflict: The Nisqually River Watershed
Click here to read about watersheds

What is the difference between a river and a watershed? Click at right to read about watersheds.

After reading "What is a Watershed?" fill out the Vocabulary Organizer.

Review concept: The Nisqually River watershed is a unified ecosystem that drains water from the source to the sea (in this case, Puget Sound). Any two drops of water that fall within the outline of this watershed, will flow towards the same outlet: the Nisqually Delta at Puget Sound.

Click here to see an outline of the Nisqually River watershed.

Part II. Review the Characters in the Conflict: The Nisqually or Squally-absch People

All land in what is now Washington State was occupied by Native American or Indian peoples before Europeans began to explore and settle in the region.

Who were these Native people and how did they use the natural resources?

Read Tribal Homelands and be sure to look at the digital maps representing how Native American territories changed over time.

Your assignment: Use this Nisqually timeline organizer. As you read, note the dates of significant events on it; this will help make your project easier later.

Your assignment: You can begin now to take notes on the sources or causes of conflict in this region. Use the Causes of Conflict Graphic Organizer to organize your notes.

Click here to read Relationship to the Mountain

Click at right to read "Relationship to the Mountain." Underline the most important concepts illustrating the traditional Nisqually relationship with the mountainous portion of the watershed.

Let's continue.

Click here to read a short biography of Chief Leschi

What happened to the Nisqually people once British and American settlers arrived? Read a short biography of "Chief Leschi" here.

Part III. Analyze Primary Sources
Click here for the primary source web gallery

Now that you have done some background reading, let's begin analyzing some primary historical materials, mainly from the Washington State Historical Society's collection.

Click into the primary source web gallery, at left, and ask yourself:

How are each of these artifacts and historic photos significant to understanding how Nisqually people felt about and used the natural environment?

 

Reminder about your assignment: Don't forget to use both your Nisqually timeline and your graphic organizer to note details about Nisqually lifeways that are revealed by these primary sources.

Part IV.  Analyze Review the Characters in the Conflict:  British Fur Traders and American Settlers

You are going to add another layer to your understanding of how the Nisqually watershed has been used by different groups of people. Let's look at how British fur traders and American settlers were using natural resources in the 1800s.

Read about the Cattle Battle here

You might be surprised to know that British fur traders and American settlers engaged in a "Cattle Battle." Read about this conflict here.

Reminder about your assignment: Since you are now reading about different groups of people, be sure to use your Causes of Conflict Graphic Organizer to note the sources of conflict over natural resources, such as pastureland. You may find that you want to take notes on an additional copy of this organizer.

Click here for image of Fort Nisqually

Now let's look at this image of the Hudson Bay Company's Fort Nisqually...

What do you see? What kinds of animals?
What kinds of man-made structures do you see?
Which ecological zone might you be looking at here (woodland, shoreline, plain)?
How is it being used?
How is this use of the Nisqually watershed similar to or different from uses you have learned about thus far?

Pull out your Causes of Conflict Graphic Organizer and continue noting some of the factors that led to conflict. What natural resources have been a source of conflict thus far in your research?

Reminder about your assignment: Continue to add to your timeline organizer because we are going to move to the 20th century and more contemporary watershed issues.

Part V.  From Iron Chinks to Carcass Toss:  Eating and Restoring Salmon
Click here to read Iron Chink

Now we are returning to the concept of watershed and fast forwarding to the early 20th century. We are going to look at how two forms of technology affected the salmon population.

Read "Iron Chink."

Answer the questions: What is an "iron chink"? How did its invention impact the salmon population?

What do you already know about the impact of building dams upon the salmon population? Why is there such interest in building these dams? What have been the consequences? Map of Nisqually River dams

Reminder: Modify your timeline and Causes of Conflict graphic organizer to include reading from this section.

Click to watch Remembering Medicine Creek

Click to read Salmon Restoration
Click to read an excerpt from Frank's Landing

Listen to another historical source - Native American oral history. In "Remembering Medicine Creek" Nisqually elder, Billy Frank, Jr., tells about Nisqually fishing traditions and the "fishing wars" of the late 1960s and 1970s.

Lastly, let's look at what people are doing today to try and recover some of the natural resources of the Nisqually River watershed.

Look at a web gallery of photos from a Salmon Carcass Toss.

 

Read "Salmon Restoration"...

 

 

...and the excerpt from the book "Frank's Landing."

 

Answer the question: What are tribal and non-tribal groups doing today to address the impacts on the watershed?

You now have a much better understanding of some of the past conflicts over the Nisqually River watershed's resource. These historic events have not only shaped the landscape but they continue to shape current events.

Part VI.  Final Research and Paper

It is time to choose you're the specific topic of your final paper.

Assignment:
Understanding the causes of conflicts may help us resolve current conflicts or even prevent future ones from occurring. You will research a conflict and analyze its causes from historical and economic perspectives.

In a persuasive paper or presentation, you will:
  1. select a conflict (see a list of ideas below) and explain how historical and economic factors helped cause the conflict
  2. using evidence to support your reasons, explain why one factor (or factors) played the biggest role in causing the conflict and
  3. cite, restate, or paraphrase and interpret relevant information from artifacts and/or primary sources

A suggested format is for you to pretend that you have been hired as a mediator to help the stakeholders resolve conflict over a Nisqually River watershed resource.

Your job, as consultant, is to help resolve an actual conflict between at least two groups.

It will be your responsibility to understand the perspectives of those in the conflict, and to submit a written report to your employer that explains the different perspectives, the causes of the conflict, and your recommended solution to the problem.

In order to make your opinion and report credible and persuasive, you must cite at least two primary sources when you represent the position of each group in the conflict.



Primary Sources: A piece of evidence created during the time period under investigation by someone who participated in, witnessed, or commented upon the events that you are studying. It is the surviving record of past events such as photographs, diaries, or artifacts.
Suggested paper topics for exploring causes of conflict:
  • Medicine Creek Treaty, 1855
  • The Puget Sound Indian War of 1855-56
  • The Trials of Chief Leschi
  • Forced relocation and founding of Fort Lewis
  • Building Dams
  • Fishing Wars and Fish Sit Ins of the 1960s and 70s
  • Salmon restoration


This webquest authored by
Patricia Pierce Erikson
Curator and Head of Education
Washington State History Museum, November 2006